Showing posts with label critique. Show all posts
Showing posts with label critique. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 9, 2009

UPDATE!

The poster is coming along well. Jon just emailed me yesterday saying he really liked the design. :)


Yesterday I screened the film for Rob and his family. I felt the movie looked great, sounded acceptable, and didn't feel like it dragged. I watched it as an audience member, and not a doting technician. Good times.

The reception was very positive overall.
I want to focus on some of the good criticism:

  • Work on the dialog from the VHS footage - so subtitles are unnecessary. Seeing "fuck" as a subtitle did not go over well. I tend to agree.

  • Build up and explain Joaquin's prowess as a sailor more. Hold on his picture a bit longer. He's a key component to why Jon went into the storm - the two of them were overconfident. This would also help separate the abrupt topic break, from "the good life" to "into the storm."

  • New & Animated map. Almost everyone wanted to geographically know where they were before the storm, and the route taken. I can see why, too - this is an easy fix and helpful.

  • Finally, I know this - but damn. I really need to EQ Jon's dialog. The lows are far too bassy, and the highs still have a lot of hiss and fuzz. For a movie that's shaping up well, it takes away from the production value.

  • The whole cat topic went over without really being mentioned. It makes me think our current intro (minus some tweaks) is working... It does saves us considerable time re-editing...

  • The new montage is strong. It starts and ends well and for once, I'm happy with it.