I'm pretty much at the last stage before the DVD is made, which is great.
Somehow, I just re-mixed all of Act 3 without a video reference file, simply using sound and knowing frame-for-frame the entire film in my head.
We added a new clip, and while it's a good one, but it threw my sync out of whack. I should have tackled the problem with a better strategy, but you live and learn.
Anyway, the final Picture is rendering now and tomorrow will simply be creating the DVD, doing some test versions, and maybe making a Surround sound mix.
Monday, October 12, 2009
Sunday, October 11, 2009
Sound mix is nearly done!
Everything is all fixed up, and now it's just a matter of getting audio levels to be ideal. Jon's dialog in Act 3 still sounds kinda bad, but it's far better than what it used to be.
Creating a screener DVD by tonight seems very possible.
Working on this film without school involved is a world of difference. The amount of tasks you can get done is astounding. I remember having 4 or 5 classes and trying to edit, it was a nightmare.
If anything, this whole experience has proven to me that you can learn just as much, if not more, outside of film school. Film school is a great place to get learn the foundations, network with people, and get gear, but I don't think I can go back to it now.
The money spent on one semester of film school could budget a professional lookin short film, and the budget spent on a year (or two) of film school could fund a very professional feature.
At the end of the day, does the degree mean more than having good work under your belt?
Creating a screener DVD by tonight seems very possible.
Working on this film without school involved is a world of difference. The amount of tasks you can get done is astounding. I remember having 4 or 5 classes and trying to edit, it was a nightmare.
If anything, this whole experience has proven to me that you can learn just as much, if not more, outside of film school. Film school is a great place to get learn the foundations, network with people, and get gear, but I don't think I can go back to it now.
The money spent on one semester of film school could budget a professional lookin short film, and the budget spent on a year (or two) of film school could fund a very professional feature.
At the end of the day, does the degree mean more than having good work under your belt?
The 5 AM editing stretch
Well, it's officially Sunday morning. 5 AM.
I'm going to sleep after an all nighter. Hopefully I don't sleep through Alan calling me at noon...
The good news:
The sound mix synced up perfectly with the final picture cut. Very cool. That's a pretty vital factor, otherwise I could spend hours tweaking it and such.
I panned a ton of effects, and added some new sounds to fill out the mix. Feels more fleshed out this way.
The current sound mix excels in a few key spots. Intro, Act 2 climax, and Montage are sounding top notch.
The bad news:
Everything else is audio peaking like nuts. I can't figure out why right now, but I'm also pretty tired. I'm sure I can fix it after sleeping. Just weird that this would happen, because I've taken many precautions to avoid this problem, so I'm a bit confused.
Some of Jon's audio is still particularly bad, but, at some point, I just have to accept it was poorly recorded. I was a clueless student at the time.
Finally, the vocals for "Before Sunrise" are not timing the way I'd like for the credit sequence. I'm not sure this can be fixed without messing with the duration of the credits, but that's not a big deal.
Overall, the sound mix is much more rich. Jon and Tim's voices are easier to hear, and that's what matters. Most likely I'll work through tomorrow and render all night. A finished screener DVD should still be ready by Monday.
I'm going to sleep after an all nighter. Hopefully I don't sleep through Alan calling me at noon...
The good news:
The sound mix synced up perfectly with the final picture cut. Very cool. That's a pretty vital factor, otherwise I could spend hours tweaking it and such.
I panned a ton of effects, and added some new sounds to fill out the mix. Feels more fleshed out this way.
The current sound mix excels in a few key spots. Intro, Act 2 climax, and Montage are sounding top notch.
The bad news:
Everything else is audio peaking like nuts. I can't figure out why right now, but I'm also pretty tired. I'm sure I can fix it after sleeping. Just weird that this would happen, because I've taken many precautions to avoid this problem, so I'm a bit confused.
Some of Jon's audio is still particularly bad, but, at some point, I just have to accept it was poorly recorded. I was a clueless student at the time.
Finally, the vocals for "Before Sunrise" are not timing the way I'd like for the credit sequence. I'm not sure this can be fixed without messing with the duration of the credits, but that's not a big deal.
Overall, the sound mix is much more rich. Jon and Tim's voices are easier to hear, and that's what matters. Most likely I'll work through tomorrow and render all night. A finished screener DVD should still be ready by Monday.
Saturday, October 10, 2009
Final Mix Session
The mixing session is coming to a close. Soundtrack Pro is a fantastic program so far and incredibly powerful. Hard to believe I'm doing this all on a little Macbook.
All that's left to do is bring back the mix to Final Cut and get everything nice and synced up again. Then I'll do a few quick tests exporting and back up all of my work.
Alan is coming by tomorrow, and I'll want him to give me his feedback. Then, the next step will be creating screener DVDs.
The finish line is very, very close!
All that's left to do is bring back the mix to Final Cut and get everything nice and synced up again. Then I'll do a few quick tests exporting and back up all of my work.
Alan is coming by tomorrow, and I'll want him to give me his feedback. Then, the next step will be creating screener DVDs.
The finish line is very, very close!
Tuesday, October 6, 2009
Today
I'm resizing the movie to 16:9, checking to see how it looks, and then locking picture once and for all. Then I'll export to Soundtrack Pro.
Priority will be:
Dialog. Jon, primarily.
B-Roll/FX tracks.
Music.
Sound bed.
Noise removal. Save this for last. I may not need that much noise reduction by the time the rest of the mix is filled out.
Other remaining things needed:
Dropping in Act 3's final music.
Changing the DVD insert to say "16:9 Widescreen" instead of "4:3 Full screen"
Removing the DVD logo.. I'm not sure it's legal to have that little logo on your case without permission or paying cash.
Priority will be:
Dialog. Jon, primarily.
B-Roll/FX tracks.
Music.
Sound bed.
Noise removal. Save this for last. I may not need that much noise reduction by the time the rest of the mix is filled out.
Other remaining things needed:
Dropping in Act 3's final music.
Changing the DVD insert to say "16:9 Widescreen" instead of "4:3 Full screen"
Removing the DVD logo.. I'm not sure it's legal to have that little logo on your case without permission or paying cash.
Testing 16:9...
Ironically enough, I just convinced myself to try it. Less sleep for me! No harm done really, we can have a 4:3 and 16:9 version.
I just have to know how it looks.
I just have to know how it looks.
New DVD Output test
I resized the whole film today, it was quite a task. Got rid of those pesky black matte bars, and made everything in the sequence 720x480i. This of course meant individually going through every shot and re-animating a ton of images.
Overall, it looks much more clean and much less of the image is cropped off. I just tested a DVD with the new look and the results are good. If the 16:9 stuff is slightly stretched, you can barely tell. I guess I could go in a nudge the distortion (barely) to give faces a bit more width.
Why did I do this? Well, most of the film is B-Roll from old school VHS tapes. Low resolution, square shaped video. All the interviews were shot 16:9 Anamorphic, Rectangle shaped video. Put them together and you naturally have an aspect ratio problem waiting to happen.
I suppose one other solution would be scaling all the VHS footage to fit within 16:9. It's possible. I'll experiment with it.
The last version of the film was:
640x480 with artificial horizontal matte bars, Pixel aspect: Rectangular.

The result was not good. Though the screenshot looks nice, the result was not. Matte bars everywhere. Vertically and horizontally, otherwise known as "mailboxing" your video. When played back on a 16:9 TV, this is some bad times. You're losing some of the image here overall in the film.
The new version is:
720x480 with no artificial matte bars. Pixel aspect: Square.

Kinda crappy screen cap but you get the idea. No matte bars on a 4:3 television, but there should be vertical ones on a 16:9 screen. The good news is, no cropping or image loss, and when this is screened at a festival, it plays as a properly formatted 4:3 SD DVD should.
That's all for now. Sound mixing tomorrow.
Overall, it looks much more clean and much less of the image is cropped off. I just tested a DVD with the new look and the results are good. If the 16:9 stuff is slightly stretched, you can barely tell. I guess I could go in a nudge the distortion (barely) to give faces a bit more width.
Why did I do this? Well, most of the film is B-Roll from old school VHS tapes. Low resolution, square shaped video. All the interviews were shot 16:9 Anamorphic, Rectangle shaped video. Put them together and you naturally have an aspect ratio problem waiting to happen.
I suppose one other solution would be scaling all the VHS footage to fit within 16:9. It's possible. I'll experiment with it.
The last version of the film was:
640x480 with artificial horizontal matte bars, Pixel aspect: Rectangular.

The result was not good. Though the screenshot looks nice, the result was not. Matte bars everywhere. Vertically and horizontally, otherwise known as "mailboxing" your video. When played back on a 16:9 TV, this is some bad times. You're losing some of the image here overall in the film.
The new version is:
720x480 with no artificial matte bars. Pixel aspect: Square.

Kinda crappy screen cap but you get the idea. No matte bars on a 4:3 television, but there should be vertical ones on a 16:9 screen. The good news is, no cropping or image loss, and when this is screened at a festival, it plays as a properly formatted 4:3 SD DVD should.
That's all for now. Sound mixing tomorrow.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)