Tuesday, October 6, 2009

New DVD Output test

I resized the whole film today, it was quite a task. Got rid of those pesky black matte bars, and made everything in the sequence 720x480i. This of course meant individually going through every shot and re-animating a ton of images.

Overall, it looks much more clean and much less of the image is cropped off. I just tested a DVD with the new look and the results are good. If the 16:9 stuff is slightly stretched, you can barely tell. I guess I could go in a nudge the distortion (barely) to give faces a bit more width.

Why did I do this? Well, most of the film is B-Roll from old school VHS tapes. Low resolution, square shaped video. All the interviews were shot 16:9 Anamorphic, Rectangle shaped video. Put them together and you naturally have an aspect ratio problem waiting to happen.

I suppose one other solution would be scaling all the VHS footage to fit within 16:9. It's possible. I'll experiment with it.


The last version of the film was:
640x480 with artificial horizontal matte bars, Pixel aspect: Rectangular.


The result was not good. Though the screenshot looks nice, the result was not. Matte bars everywhere. Vertically and horizontally, otherwise known as "mailboxing" your video. When played back on a 16:9 TV, this is some bad times. You're losing some of the image here overall in the film.

The new version is:
720x480 with no artificial matte bars. Pixel aspect: Square.

Kinda crappy screen cap but you get the idea. No matte bars on a 4:3 television, but there should be vertical ones on a 16:9 screen. The good news is, no cropping or image loss, and when this is screened at a festival, it plays as a properly formatted 4:3 SD DVD should.

That's all for now. Sound mixing tomorrow.

No comments:

Post a Comment