Ironically enough, I just convinced myself to try it. Less sleep for me! No harm done really, we can have a 4:3 and 16:9 version.
I just have to know how it looks.
Tuesday, October 6, 2009
New DVD Output test
I resized the whole film today, it was quite a task. Got rid of those pesky black matte bars, and made everything in the sequence 720x480i. This of course meant individually going through every shot and re-animating a ton of images.
Overall, it looks much more clean and much less of the image is cropped off. I just tested a DVD with the new look and the results are good. If the 16:9 stuff is slightly stretched, you can barely tell. I guess I could go in a nudge the distortion (barely) to give faces a bit more width.
Why did I do this? Well, most of the film is B-Roll from old school VHS tapes. Low resolution, square shaped video. All the interviews were shot 16:9 Anamorphic, Rectangle shaped video. Put them together and you naturally have an aspect ratio problem waiting to happen.
I suppose one other solution would be scaling all the VHS footage to fit within 16:9. It's possible. I'll experiment with it.
The last version of the film was:
640x480 with artificial horizontal matte bars, Pixel aspect: Rectangular.

The result was not good. Though the screenshot looks nice, the result was not. Matte bars everywhere. Vertically and horizontally, otherwise known as "mailboxing" your video. When played back on a 16:9 TV, this is some bad times. You're losing some of the image here overall in the film.
The new version is:
720x480 with no artificial matte bars. Pixel aspect: Square.

Kinda crappy screen cap but you get the idea. No matte bars on a 4:3 television, but there should be vertical ones on a 16:9 screen. The good news is, no cropping or image loss, and when this is screened at a festival, it plays as a properly formatted 4:3 SD DVD should.
That's all for now. Sound mixing tomorrow.
Overall, it looks much more clean and much less of the image is cropped off. I just tested a DVD with the new look and the results are good. If the 16:9 stuff is slightly stretched, you can barely tell. I guess I could go in a nudge the distortion (barely) to give faces a bit more width.
Why did I do this? Well, most of the film is B-Roll from old school VHS tapes. Low resolution, square shaped video. All the interviews were shot 16:9 Anamorphic, Rectangle shaped video. Put them together and you naturally have an aspect ratio problem waiting to happen.
I suppose one other solution would be scaling all the VHS footage to fit within 16:9. It's possible. I'll experiment with it.
The last version of the film was:
640x480 with artificial horizontal matte bars, Pixel aspect: Rectangular.

The result was not good. Though the screenshot looks nice, the result was not. Matte bars everywhere. Vertically and horizontally, otherwise known as "mailboxing" your video. When played back on a 16:9 TV, this is some bad times. You're losing some of the image here overall in the film.
The new version is:
720x480 with no artificial matte bars. Pixel aspect: Square.

Kinda crappy screen cap but you get the idea. No matte bars on a 4:3 television, but there should be vertical ones on a 16:9 screen. The good news is, no cropping or image loss, and when this is screened at a festival, it plays as a properly formatted 4:3 SD DVD should.
That's all for now. Sound mixing tomorrow.
Monday, October 5, 2009
The final week of production
Last night we met with Tom Benson, one of Jon's former shipmates. We screened the film for him and he enjoyed it. Made him a copy, and I'm happy to get his approval.
As much as I'd like to reflect on the evening, I have a ton of work to do.
It's time to meet deadlines. I dealt with it before during Epidemic, but now this is a self-imposed. If I work extremely hard this week, I know I can do it.
My task list for this week:
Prepare Intro to be mixed by Dean. Make some slight changes to his sinking sequence mix too.
Clean up pre-existing B-Roll photos in Photoshop. Possibly re-animate if time allows.
Add new Before/After B-Roll of Jon's boat blueprints, transitioning to the final finished boat. For Act 1.
Modify credit sequence to reflect updated changes.
Get the remaining music from Chris Waltz, mix it, drop it in.
Finalize all music decisions. Transition from FCP to Soundtrack Pro.
Complete a final mix of the entire film. Who knows how much time I'll have, but I'll try my best. Obviously, mixing dialog is first priority.
Export to FCP - Convert Project to 480i, remove matte bars, re-render highest quality. Prep everything for DVD exporting.
Hopefully, we'll have time to play a final cut of the film for Brad Hughes. My guess is probably not.
Either way, I'll export to DVD, test and re-test it, and then send it off to festivals.
My goal is to do all of this by Saturday, Oct. 10th.
----
I predict some all nighters. I predict lots of stress too, but I will definitely get this finished!
As much as I'd like to reflect on the evening, I have a ton of work to do.
It's time to meet deadlines. I dealt with it before during Epidemic, but now this is a self-imposed. If I work extremely hard this week, I know I can do it.
My task list for this week:
Prepare Intro to be mixed by Dean. Make some slight changes to his sinking sequence mix too.
Clean up pre-existing B-Roll photos in Photoshop. Possibly re-animate if time allows.
Add new Before/After B-Roll of Jon's boat blueprints, transitioning to the final finished boat. For Act 1.
Modify credit sequence to reflect updated changes.
Get the remaining music from Chris Waltz, mix it, drop it in.
Finalize all music decisions. Transition from FCP to Soundtrack Pro.
Complete a final mix of the entire film. Who knows how much time I'll have, but I'll try my best. Obviously, mixing dialog is first priority.
Export to FCP - Convert Project to 480i, remove matte bars, re-render highest quality. Prep everything for DVD exporting.
Hopefully, we'll have time to play a final cut of the film for Brad Hughes. My guess is probably not.
Either way, I'll export to DVD, test and re-test it, and then send it off to festivals.
My goal is to do all of this by Saturday, Oct. 10th.
----
I predict some all nighters. I predict lots of stress too, but I will definitely get this finished!
Tuesday, September 29, 2009
Finished DVD Insert
Monday, September 28, 2009
Sunday, September 27, 2009
Testing
Poster... Compare / contrast
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





